Something unprecedented happened on Come Dine With Me last week and no one could quite figure out what had happened: a contestant was booted off the show by the producers.

But up until now, no one really knew what had happened behind the scenes that had resulted in Rory Nicoll simply vanishing in the next episode! Until now!

During the first night, an argument broke out amongst the contestants about Take That. Yep, Take That. It seems that Rory was very firm in his belief that Gary Barlow was the most talented member of the band while his dinner guests disagreed. A huge row broke out which you can see below:

Credit: Channel 4

Things got very heated and a few feathers were ruffled. And according to Jennifer Judge who was also appearing on the show at the time, eventually Rory was given an ultimatum by the show's producers, either apologise for his Gary Barlow comments or get out. And he chose to stay true to the cause and was removed. Awkward:

I loved meeting the others, and me and my husband are going along to one of their 40th birthdays," Jennifer said.
There was a bit of a drama, though, and a first on the show.
On the first night, everybody came to mine, and on the second night the host had a bit of an argument with the other gentleman.
The producer said if the host didn't apologise, he would get kicked off the show and he didn't!

So that clears up that mystery!

Now the only question left to answer is this: is Gary Barlow really the most talented member of Take That or was Rory talking out of his *rse? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!

Jack Rear

Jack is a writer at Pretty52. His hobbies include charging admission at weddings and eating glitter. Rumour has it he was thrown out of Taylor Swift's squad for showing too much belly button.

Next Up

arrow-down arrow-left arrow-right arrow-up camera clock close comment cursor email facebook-messenger facebook Instagram link new-window phone play share snapchat submit twitter vine whatsapp safari-pinned-tab